Best Pizza in Hilton Head

Pizza in Hilton Head

Are you planning a Hilton Head vacation? Here’s one thing you shouldn’t miss out on: pizza! There’s nothing quite like a delicious pizza before or after strolling through pristine beaches, playing golf on world-class courses, or exploring the island’s bike trails.

There are several pizza places in Hilton Head, and this list will share the must-try ones. Read on to discover mouthwatering variations of one of the world’s favorite food items.

1. Local Pie

If you’re looking for legit Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizza, Local Pie is the place to be. There’s no other restaurant quite like it on the island. The brand boasts the highest quality, regionally-sourced ingredients and a team of local staff that represent the Hilton Head community.

Local Pie offers classics like Margherita and more adventurous flavors like Mr. Mittake — a pizza with a roasted garlic spread base mixed with truffle oil and cheeses.

There are different ways to enjoy the food from this shop. You can drop by 55 New Orleans Road to enjoy made-for-you or build-your-own pies. You can also choose to order online via Cool Delivery.

Either way, you’ll surely love everything, from the pizza to the salads, calzones, and desserts!

2. Giuseppi’s

Since 1984, Giuseppi’s has been serving Hilton Head locals and tourists award-winning pizzas and well-prepared pasta, sandwiches, salads, and more. The brand insists on using only the freshest, most authentic ingredients for its clients.

At this pizzeria, there’s something for everyone to enjoy. It’s a great place for large groups with kids, sports enthusiasts who want to catch football games, and those looking for a spot to unwind. The last group can’t go wrong with the full bar of over 16 beers on tap, which celebrates happy hour every Monday to Friday from 4:00 to 6:00 PM.

Guiseppi’s Hilton Head is open for lunch and dinner and is available for online delivery.

3. Mellow Mushroom

Artsy pizza lovers, unite! Mellow Mushroom will gladly address your love for aesthetics, great food, and yes, mushroom art. If you’re looking for a funky pizzeria with creative stone-baked pizzas and craft beer, search no more because this restaurant has it all.

Mellow Mushroom offers a wide range of products, from pizzas to munchies to burgers. Diners can also enjoy magic mocktails and enchanted iced teas. And while the Buffalo Chicken and Funky Q. Chicken are some of the bestsellers, guests can request gluten-free or vegan food options.

Whether you want to dine in, do a curbside pickup, or order online, the team can make it happen.

4. Fat Baby’s

Is thin-crust pie your jam? Then you’ll love Fat Baby’s. Locals and tourists alike can’t get enough of this restaurant’s pizzas.

If you’re looking for a family-friendly joint with great food and affordable prices, check out this pizzeria next time you’re in Hilton Head. With its relaxing setting with a jukebox and TVs, kids and the young at heart will surely have a great time!

Fat Baby’s is home to some of the island’s most famous comfort food. Favorites include The Fat Baby pizza, French Dip sub, and fried homemade mozzarella. Go visit the restaurant at 1034 William Hilton Parkway or order online to discover why everybody in Hilton Head recommends it.

5. Mangiamo’s

Mangiamo’s is a laid-back pizza restaurant in Hilton Head that peaks during football season because of its big-screen TVs and happy hour. It specializes in pizza, pasta, wings, and secret homemade sauces that keep locals coming back for more.

The menu offers various options, making it hard to choose a favorite. However, you really can’t go wrong with garlic bread, honey BBQ chicken wings, shrimp pizza, and some cheese ravioli. Bigger groups can also add calzones and strombolis to the mix.

Next time you’re on the island, check out the restaurant at 2000 Main St. or request online delivery via Grubhub. Note that the pizzeria closes every Monday and otherwise operates from 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM.

Need Help Planning Your Hilton Head Vacation?

Okay, so we’ve covered the best pizza places on the island. On your next visit, check out Local Pie, Giuseppi’s, Mellow Mushroom, Fat Baby’s, and Mangiamo’s. They’re the standouts in Hilton Head, and all of them have something different to offer.

If you still need help with other aspects of your vacation, like rentals, activities, or guest services, call Beachside Hilton Head Island at (843) 342-9909. The team will guide you with all the info you need.