You’ve just arrived at your Beachside Hilton Head vacation rental and you suddenly feel the need to find the perfect slice of pizza to kick off your getaway. Luckily, Hilton Head is home to some fantastic pizzerias! We’ve scoured the island to bring you the ultimate pizza guide.

Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta

Address: 50 Shelter Cove Lane, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

Phone: (843) 785-4144

Our pizza quest begins at Giuseppi’s Pizza & Pasta, a winner of the Island Packet newspaper’s Reader’s Choice Award for Best Pizza. Giuseppi’s has been a go-to destination for pizza lovers for over three decades! The eatery’s menu also has an array of fresh plates of pasta, succulent wings, delectable sandwiches, and more.

Dough Boys Pizza

Address: 1 New Orleans Rd Unit B, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

Phone: (843) 686-2697

Since December 2013, Dough Boys Pizza has joyously catered to patrons, garnering a reputation over the subsequent nine years as the purveyor of the Island’s Best Pizza. Its menu exceeds exquisite pizzas, delighting customers with the freshest chopped salads, distinctively crafted subs, and tantalizing appetizers!

Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs

Address: 1034 William Hilton Parkway, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

Phone: (843) 842-4200

Mirroring the quintessential neighborhood pizza places from the ’70s, Fat Baby’s Pizza & Subs is renowned for its homemade pizzas and family-friendly ambiance. The Fat Baby Pizza, their signature dish, is a sure delight! You can also grab anything from their merchandise line on your visit.

Il Carpaccio Ristorante

Address: 200A Museum Street, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926

Phone: (843)342-9949

For genuine Italian-style pizza in Hilton Head, Il Carpaccio‘s co-owner hails from a locality close to Venice, and their wood-fired oven is a direct import from Modena, Italy. Every pizza showcases a tantalizingly thin and savory crust layered with irresistible sauce, cheese, and an array of toppings.

Local Pie

Address: 55 New Orleans Rd #106, Hilton Head Island, SC 29928

Phone: (843) 842-7437

Embodying its name, Local Pie is a pizzeria that champions the use of local provisions and farms. The pizza place excels in whipping up mouth-watering Neapolitan-style pizzas baked to the right degree in a wood-fired brick oven. Try their featured pies or build your own!

TJ’s Take & Bake Pizza

Address: 35 North Main Street, In The J.Banks Complex, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926

Phone: (843) 681-2900

TJ’s Take & Bake takes the crown with its rich and varied menu of unique pizzas, each prepared fresh using a secret dough recipe. TJ’s commitment to quality is evident in their unrivaled pizza sauce, freshly prepared each day. Generous topping portions are another highlight, a quality that sets them apart.


Address: 2000 Main St, Hilton Head Island, SC 29926

Phone: (843) 682-2444

Mangiamo strikes the perfect balance of crust thickness, subtly sweet sauce, and a harmonious blend of cheeses. With a comprehensive menu featuring traditional Italian cuisine, delectable salads, and an excellent selection of beers, Mangiamo ensures a delightful dining experience.

Savor Every Slice of Paradise With Beachside Hilton Head

As you explore Hilton Head’s stunning beauty and enjoy the comforts of your Beachside Hilton Head vacation rental, embark on a culinary journey through these pizzerias. Hilton Head is waiting to delight you with pizza paradise.